Japan has long been at the forefront of cashless public transportation with its Suica IC card system. Now, with the introduction of Welcome Suica Mobile, visitors to Japan have a new digital option for seamless travel. But how does it compare to other available Suica options, such as Apple Pay Suica, physical Welcome Suica, and the regular Suica card? This guide breaks down the differences, benefits, and drawbacks of each, helping you determine the best choice for your needs.
While you’re in Japan, come to Kyoto for breathtaking photography and expertly guided tours–check out PiQtour’s photography services and tours to enhance your travel experience!
What is Welcome Suica Mobile? 📱
Welcome Suica Mobile is a digital, prepaid transit card exclusively for short-term foreign visitors to Japan. Available via a dedicated Welcome Suica Mobile app, it eliminates the need for a physical card while allowing for easy top-ups via Apple Pay. However, it comes with some limitations that travelers should be aware of.
Comparison: Welcome Suica Mobile vs. Other Suica Options 🔍
| Feature | Welcome Suica Mobile | Apple Wallet | Welcome Suica (physical card) | Suica Card |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Device Compatibility | iPhone 8 or later, Apple Watch Series 3 or later | iPhone 8 or later, Apple Watch Series 3 or later | Any IC-compatible device | Any IC-compatible device |
| Balance Expiration | 128 days from issue, non-renewable | No expiration | 28 days from issue | No expiration |
| Refund Policy | No refunds | Refundable (fees may apply) | No refunds | Refundable (fees may apply) |
| Top-Up Method | Apple Pay only | Apple Pay*, Japan-issued credit cards, cash (convenience stores, ticket machines) | Cash at stations, ticket machines | Cash at stations, convenience stores, Japan-issued credit cards |
| Use for Shinkansen | Limited (Fall 2026: Non-reserved JR East Shinkansen only) | Full compatibility with Express Reservation (EX) & Smart EX | Limited (same as mobile version) | Full compatibility with Shinkansen reservations |
| Japanese Address Required? | No | Yes (for online services) | No | No |
*Some users have difficulty topping up depending on the card issuer or time of day.
Who is Welcome Suica Mobile For? 🎯
✅ Ideal for:
- Short-term visitors who want a quick and easy mobile transit card.
- Travelers who don’t want to deal with physical Suica cards.
- Users who only need the card for transit and small in-store purchases.
❌ Not ideal for:
- Long-term visitors or frequent Japan travelers (better options: Apple Pay Suica or Regular Suica Card).
- Those who need Shinkansen reservations (Mobile Suica with Express Reservation is the best choice).
- People wanting refundable balance (only standard Mobile Suica and physical Suica allow refunds).
Drawbacks of Welcome Suica Mobile ⚠️
- 128-day Expiration: The balance is non-refundable and expires, making it unsuitable for frequent visitors.
- Limited Shinkansen Support: Unlike Apple Pay Suica, you cannot use it for seat reservations.
- Apple Pay-Only Top-Ups: Users with non-Japanese credit cards may face issues adding funds.
- Can’t Be Managed from Abroad: Unlike Apple Pay Suica, Welcome Suica Mobile cannot be topped up internationally.
Apple Wallet: The Best Option for Long-Term Visitors? 📲
Unlike Welcome Suica Mobile, the standard Apple Pay Suica is a much better long-term option for frequent visitors or foreign residents. Here’s why:
- ✅ No Expiration – The balance remains indefinitely valid.
- ✅ Recharge from Anywhere – If linked to an Apple Pay-compatible card, you can top up even outside Japan.
- ✅ Fully Compatible with Shinkansen Reservations – Works with Express Reservation and Smart EX for long-distance travel.
- ✅ Refundable Balance – Unlike Welcome Suica Mobile, any unused balance can be refunded (fees may apply).
💡 The Catch? You need a Japanese Apple ID to set it up, and non-Japanese credit cards might not always work for direct top-ups.
Final Recommendations: Which Suica Should You Choose? ✅
Choose Welcome Suica Mobile if…
✔️ You’re a short-term visitor who just needs a simple, cashless way to travel in Japan.
✔️ You want a mobile version of Suica without dealing with physical cards.
✔️ You don’t need Shinkansen seat reservations.
Choose Apple Wallet if…
✔️ You visit Japan frequently and want to keep Suica active even outside Japan.
✔️ You need full Shinkansen support and prefer to make seat reservations.
✔️ You want more flexibility with top-ups and refunds.
Choose Welcome Suica (physical card) if…
✔️ You don’t use Apple devices but still want a transit pass for a short trip.
✔️ You don’t mind carrying a physical card and topping up at stations.
✔️ You don’t need a long-term option.
Choose Suica (regular physical card) if…
✔️ You’re a long-term resident or frequent traveler looking for a permanent IC card.
✔️ You want the ability to recharge with cash, credit cards, or Apple Pay.
✔️ You need a refundable option that doesn’t expire.
Final Thoughts 💡
While Welcome Suica Mobile is a convenient addition for visitors, it’s best for short-term use only. Frequent Japan travelers should consider Apple Pay Suica or a regular Suica card for more flexibility and long-term usability. Understanding these differences will help you choose the best Suica for your trip!
For more guides and tips on all things Japan, check out the PiQtour YouTube page!
Relevant Keyphrases: Welcome Suica Mobile, Apple Pay Suica, JR East Suica, Japan IC cards, mobile transit cards Japan, Suica vs PASMO, Japan cashless payments, Shinkansen ticketing, Suica top-up, Japan public transport tips